Boundless Way Zen

James Ishmael Ford, Senseiclick to email



talksandteishos.gif (1802 bytes)
METHOD
Sesshin Teisho by John Tarrant Roshi
September, 1991  Day Two
Perth, Australia

Usually, around this time of sesshin we become aware that we have
bodies and the bodies start complaining somewhat.  I thought I'd talk
a little bit about ways of working with the body.  It's easy to ignore
when you are following a spiritual path, but it doesn't hurt to be a
bit sophisticated about the way we do it.  So when you have a lot of
pain, there are a number of ways to deal with it.  One way is to just
sort of grit on through, and, you know, that works for some people
pretty much all the time.  If that works for you, that's fine.  I like
you to be at least aware of other ways, however, because there are
some things in life that don't work when we just blunder through them
and it is good to discover other ways of dealing with what comes up.
When the heroic path begins to fail us and our knees keep hurting even
though we have lots of courage and effort, then one of the most
interesting ways is to go into the suffering, and this is whether the
suffering is physical or of the other kind.

I'll talk about physical suffering first.  I think that's the easiest
to deal with.  When we deal with that, we can get a sense of how to
deal with other kinds of suffering as well.  One ancient Buddhist way
of dealing with the body is the method of sweeping which I'm sure some
of you have studied.  It is more popular in the Tibetan and Theravadan
traditions than in the zen tradition, but it's known in all Buddhist
traditions.  For example, if you have a pain in your knee, one way you
can deal with it is just to begin sweeping your attention into you
body. Usually you start at the top at the crown chakra.  It doesn't
really matter too much, but why not?  You sweep your attention through
your body and suddenly everything will become alive, and what you are
focussed on will not be so strong because it is not the only in the
field.  It is no longer in the foreground.  If your knee was hurting,
it is no longer in the foreground.  If you were obsessed with
something, that is no longer in the foreground and in the sweeping way
you sweep through.  If you are going to do the full thing, you sweep
slowly through your whole body (and it usually takes me about an hour,
I guess) right down to the toes, and you'll find the kind of
liveliness and that interchange between the mind and the body is
always going on.  The way physical sensation turns into thoughts which
turn into feelings which turn into physical sensation and so on.  The
usual talkative quality of the body.  I think this method just gets
you friendly with the body so that you realize that it is not
something to be overcome, really, as the Buddha's vehicle itself.
Without being there is no Buddha.  Without this narrow limiting body
that is either complaining or singing, then there is no Buddha;
without the eucalypt tree there is no Buddha.

To return to the idea of the pain in the knee always, one of my
favorites.  If you have a strong pain in the knee, you can go to it;
if you have a headache, you can go to it, which is counter to the
usual style of the ego.  Usually we flee suffering.  In zen, instead
of fleeing life and muting it and dulling it, we experience it more
fully and then it starts to flower.  It is like that with the pain.
If you go into the pain, it's quite interesting.  Some pains, when you
go into them, you just go straight into it and it will start to
transform if you just hold it in your awareness.  Other pains will
start to amplify intolerably.  You can tell already that method is
about differentiation.  The method is about, well, what kind of pain
is this, or what kind of time an I in?  Is this the time to go into
the pain or not?  It's a matter of try it and see.  You know that good
old Buddhist empirical sense of try it and, well, that didn't work.
Try something else.  You'll find if you go into the pain, sometimes it
will start to shift, just like that.  If it doesn't, you can also try
leaving it, try embracing it, welcoming it.  Sometimes that will
change something.  You can't be tricky, though, and embrace it so that
it will change.  You just have to embrace it.  Too much ego in thatthe
strategic approach.

Then another interesting thing that I think is perhaps the most
powerful of these.  Let's say you have a pain in the knee start up.
Put your awareness into the middle of the thigh.  Something else is
happening there.  Then sweep down through the knee into your calf, and
maybe, sweep back up and feel what it is like to cross the border into
the pain.  Pain, too, has borders.  When we are in pain, we think it
fills the universe.  Pain always comes with a message, "I fill the
universe and don't think there is anything else.

It is the same with emotional pain.  We notice that pain, too, has
margins.  We can cross them and we can cross them back.  This way you
are less likely to damage your body because your muscles will relax.
Then you'll know when your body is really serious and you need to
shift, or when your body is just sort of complaining because you are
sad or bored or whatever.  Gradually we get to be more friendly with
ourselves in this way.

There are other more elaborate ways of dealing with pain.  For
example, if you visualize a thousand armed elevenheaded Kwan Yin with
each head a different color and each arm holding something, then that
Kwan Yin sinks into the top of your head and you become that Kwan Yin
and it fills your body with golden light.  That will probably deal
with the pain, too.  This is a legitimate meditation, but takes a
while to get the hang of it.  To fill yourself with light can also
work.  Some people are very visual. If you are one of these people,
try that and then the pain just floats up and bubbles of light harming
no one, abiding nowhere, getting transformed into light and joy with
the sorrows and joys and obsessions, memories and all the other things
that you know come up.  The dull torpor that takes us over. The bovine
sort of ignorance that will hold us in its thrall for an hour, then
another hour.  The intense longing for sleep.  The obsession of
whether or not you are doing things right.  The obsession of whether
or not somebody else is doing things right.  The desire for revenge.
Many things come up in people.  Don't be too snobbish about whatever
your particular passion is when it comes up.  You might as well have
something, and you might as well work with what you've got rather than
wishing you had somebody else's. But also, don't be afraid of it.

The clear way in zen is to focus on the subject of the meditation,
focus on the koan, focus on the breath.  Let it fill the universe and
if you can do that, that's good.  There will be times when that seems
to run out, if you are anything like me. Then it is sometimes helpful
to get interesteda little bit interestedin what the condition is.  In
other words, to break all the rules, which is a good zen thing to do,
of course. Sometimes we will spend hours fighting something when we
could have just noticed it for a few minutes and transformed it.  So
try that.  I am not saying to be seduced by every passing thought or
fancy.  But if something strong is coming up in you, begin to notice a
little.  Does it have a name?  Has it been with you a long time?  Is
it always with you?  When is it with you?  But it is a kind of
undertone to you life?  Maybe it is a way of seeing things that comes
up where you arealways a little bit irritable, or a little bit
despairing, or a little bit anxious, a little bit critical.  So don't
be afraid to just experience. What is it like?  What is the body like
if you are angry?  How does it speak?  What images come to you?  That
way you get familiar.  You can say, "Oh hello, anger.  Come in and sit
down. I am doing my koan.  Why don't you join me?"  Which is a very
different attitude to life than trying to cut it off all the time.
Perhaps, later in sesshin I should speak about the virtues of cutting
off, too, which has its own power, but now I think I want to convey
the important point that nothing that comes up is alien.  Terence, I
think, said, "Nothing human is alien." Nothing that comes up will
overwhelm you, so you can afford to look at it a little bit.

Different things, again, have different qualities.  It's like physical
pain.  Some kinds of anxieties come up and grab people, so sometimes
we are afraid to look because we will get caught in the spell and
panic.  We are afraid that it will overwhelm us. But remember that a
strong emotion always comes with a message that it fills the universe,
but it does not fill the universe. There are always the trees, the
flowers, other emotions, other people, other things in the world,
other things that you like or dislike or are ignorant about.  When you
can just get the awareness that this does not fill the universe, that
awareness is your treasure.  It doesn't mean that you have to push the
emotion away or do something about it.  That's too much of the ego
level heroic knowing.  When something comes up, it is enough to just
witness it; enough to say:  Oh, now I am anxious; now I am desperate
to get enlightened, then I won't have to pay my taxes; or then I won't
have to deal with my boyfriend, girlfriend, husband, wife, exhusband,
boss, child, whatever.  As the zazen progresses, I shall be able to
deal better with the world.  So don't be afraid to experience what
comes up.  If you are working on a great koan such as "Mu" or "Who is
hearing?" or any of the great koans, you will find that your koan is
right there.  This is not doing something different from you koan than
in the deep world of meditation.  Things that are contradictory are no
longer contradictory.

Sometimes I think cultures have their different styles of obsession.
One of the Australian styles is the sort of battler image, I think,
where everybody sort of minimizes everything. Somebody wraps a
motorcycle around a tree and some guy is bleeding and in pieces and
everybody says, "Oh, a bit of a physic and he'll be up and about in no
time."  But it also goes for minimizing joy.  Let's not enjoy it too
much because somebody might steal it.  Let's not pull together too
much because somebody might disappoint me.  Let me not try too hard
because I shall feel worthless and ignorant.  So some people are not
subject to strong passion, but to this kind of inertia.  This kind of
rather dull, placid kind of security where we don't risk anything.  If
that is your condition, too, then notice it. Notice how it kills your
body.  Notice how it changes all human interactions that you have.

Despair, another good one.  Despair says that things do not have
meaning and that all the effort I have done is completely wasted;
moreover, somebody is probably deluding me.  That's when it goes over
to paranoid as hell.  Another personal favorite, paranoia is a kind of
inverse enlightenment where everything is connected, but it is pointed
at you.  Despair is the submission to the Cartesian universe where
there are all these separate objects in space.  They just ban about
and bang off each other where there is no meaning and no love and no
grace in the world.  Notice that, too, if that comes up; it, too,
seems to fill the universe, but does not.

What we develop by this kind of noticing is something I think of as
integrity.  Integrity, as you know, refers to wholeness and is
associated with self knowledge.  Gradually, through the years of zazen
integrity builds.  Integrity is like love in the long run. It has a
lot to do with duration.  Falling in love takes no time just like
enlightenment, but integrity takes time just like loving does.  It is
something that endures and goes on; it comes from many small choices;
it is like the incense ash, piling up with the years of zazen.
Integrity, then, gives us an inner guidance.  When we put our
attention inside, we find out, "Oh yes, this is what I must do."  This
is the way to go and it is very different from impulsive decisions.
Other times we go inside and integrity tells us, "I don't have a clue
which way to go here."   Then our integrity will hold us so that we
are willing not to know and we know that not knowing is the best we
can do right now and we are willing, then,to trust it; that it, too,
comes out of the Tao, out of the magical source of all things.  So we
are not always soaring about and thinking zen is the best thing in the
world and then the worst thing in the world, or taking it up and
giving it up, the way many of us do often when we begin zen.
Integrity relates to the healing and opening quality of zazen.
Enlightenment deals with doubt and we see the glowing, shining quality
of the universe and know there is a path.  Integrity holds us steady
so that we can get to walk that path.  It is part of the road itself.
The integrity is just as important.

I think of the distinction between false and true suffering in this
context.  True suffering is what we have because we are human.  The
Buddha pointed out that suffering is the underpinning of being human.
There is an old zen saying that there is no satori without tears.  If
you didn't suffer, you wouldn't want to do zen anyway, and if you are
not willing to suffer, you don't get so far in zen.  But if you are
willing to suffer, that is the true suffering.  The true suffering is
when we have a loss and we are sad, and I guess the false suffering is
all the stuff we do not want to be sad and make a nuisance of
ourselves to ourselves and others.  The false suffering is, you know,
we have a bad day at work and come home and yell at somebody, or
somebody leaves us and then we yell at somebody else.  We get angry
when we are sad. The false suffering is the kind of turmoil we make
around things and we are always making it.  I think our integrity lets
us pick this out.  It tells us when it is appropriate to weep and when
it's not; when we need to cut through and keep going; when the timing
is right and we've been grieving long enough.  It is time to let go
now, to cut off and then it is time to go into something.  That
distinction has a lot to do with false and true suffering.

We attend to process in zen.  Zen and Buddhism, generally, are process
paths.  They are not so much bodies of theory, of books, of belief,
but practices like gardening or healing.  Practices can't really be
taught that well in schools.  They are done through sweat and
attention to process or having a mentor.  And eventually by osmosis.
So we learn to attend to process.  We may have started out attending
to our lives so that later on we might% 0*''live, but we come to see
that attention itself is living. Awareness itself is full of grace and
joy and beauty and then we come to the fullness of life.  When we are
willing to have our true suffering and to cut off our false suffering,
life is very rich.  The bread, the tea, love, the rain, sorrow, all
are much stronger tasting and all have their own value and beauty.
Even the hardest things have their value and beauty, even the occasion
of suffering, even somebody dying, even somebody dying hard. (Not
everyone dies gracefully as in the hospice.)  Pictures.  So everything
becomes alive because we participate with it.  And then we realize
that integrity is self knowledge.  The self is much wider than we
thought.  The self is everybody in this room sweating away, all our
dear companions of zazen, and how when I sweat away, in some way I
hold up other people, and when I'm weak, they hold me up.

One of the things about attention that I think is very important,
that's a small thing but we often don't do well, is to appreciate the
joy when it comes.  Life is full of joy and we can step past itfinding
what does not fit; finding what there is to complain about.  It is as
if there is a kind of resistance in us that snatches joys.  A critical
voice that says, "You are not doing it right," or "Do it this way,
always," commenting on everything from zazen to breakfast.  To how the
leaders are doing; to how somebody you love is doing; to how somebody
you can't stand is doing, and that's not useful.  That critical voice
comes up over and over again.  I think you know what I mean by that.
Most people have some experience of it and in zen that's where you
need to wield the sword.  You need to notice that critical voice when
it is coming in.  People often misidentify that with something; with
virtue and zen because it's saying sit up straight, do this, do that,
and they think that that is zen, but that's not zen.  That's just the
critical voice being a pain. You can understand it has nothing to do
with that deep inner enquiry, that deep inner reverence that is the
true spirit of zen, which says, "Oh, what is this coming up?" rather
than the critical voice which says, "I shouldn't be feeling, I should
be doing `Mu'."  I shouldn't be experiencing this, not realizing that.
That voice itself is what takes you farthest from your koan.  So wield
your sword on that.  Then the joy rises naturally.  When the pain is
there, you work with the pain, and you'll find the joy is within the
pain.

Joshu had a wonderful old koan called, "The Oak Tree in the Garden."
Somebody asked him what is the meaning of Bodhidharma's coming from
the West?  Bodhidharma, as you know, was the person who brought zazen
from India to China, one of the many people who did that, the one who
is now remembered.  So what is the meaning of all this work of the
Way.  Joshu said, "The oak tree in the garden."  When he said that, he
pointed out the great strangeness of the Way.  How the most familiar
thing, when we really look at it, fills the universe and changes us,
and it is not what we thought it was.  It is something magnificent,
full of life, and each moment of zen is that way.  So when I say
appreciate your joy, I just mean be open.  Do not fix too much around
the thoughts that come up.  When we are aware of them, we have
integrity.  They roll through eventually.  We don't fix on them so you
have this scan roll in the mind.  Keizan said there is always
something in the mind and that's true.  Even if it is only the idea
that there is nothing in the mind, or that there shouldn't be
something in the mind, or whatever it is.  But there is this slow,
beautiful roll that is life itself.  The process itself.  The Tao
talking to itself which is what we all are really.  Buddha nature
conversing, playing, full of light and joy.

Please keep up your zazen.

 

Click to email

HOME